Pre Workout VS Energy Drink – Supplement Reviews Blog

Pre Workout VS Energy Drink – Supplement Reviews Blog
Spread the love

Pre Exercise VS Vitality Drink

It’s 2020 and with the brand new yr, we wish to mirror on what’s completely different and what’s to return. From streaming-service wars to power drinks, it’s laborious to maintain up with all the brand new and outdated firms. That’s the place we are available in! On this publish, we’re masking a few of your favourite power drinks (like Reign™ and Monster) and their competitors; the ready-to-drink (RTD) pre exercise!

So what are literally going to cowl? As per traditional, we’ve damaged it down right here:

We’re going to go as in-depth as attainable, however we might run into some proprietary blends alongside the best way. So we’ll do our greatest to generalize throughout merchandise when attainable.

pre workout vs energy drink

Pre Exercise VS Vitality Drink: What’s Thought-about Wholesome?

That is truly form of troublesome query to reply. Primarily as a result of wholesome is completely different for everybody.

Earlier than we are able to begin evaluating merchandise, now we have to have a baseline of what’s splendid in our model of wholesome. In our splendid power drink, now we have potent sources of power and focus, BCAAs and/or Electrolytes (for re-hydration and muscle restore), low energy or no energy, and a few nice flavors with out the after-a-energy-drink aftertaste.

Let’s additionally sort out a number of the widespread options in RTD merchandise…


Preservative components are used to stop deterioration and spoilage. It additionally helps prolong shelf life. 

Bodily strategies to protect meals and drinks embrace freezing, refrigerating and/or drying. The opposite methodology of preservation is thru chemical compounds. Chemical preservation includes “components”, however there are various naturally occurring chemical preservatives corresponding to salts.

Some widespread chemical preservatives embrace:

sugar and sweeteners

Sugar, Sweeteners, and Flavoring!

The FDA has authorized 5 synthetic sweeteners: saccharin, acesulfame, aspartame, neotame, and sucralose. 

As you’ll be able to think about, there’s extra to synthetic sweeteners than being a sugar various. In actual fact, one animal examine means that synthetic sweetener could also be addictive. (1) Typically, it seems that there’s a lapse in analysis for long run utilization of synthetic sweeteners. Nonetheless, there are dangers related to each day consumption of drinks with excessive quantity of synthetic sweeteners, together with metabolic syndrome and sort 2 diabetes. 

So what about common sugar?

Sugar accommodates its personal set of dangers together with rising blood glucose ranges and insulin, inflammatory mediators, triglyceride and different circumstances. 


In pre exercises and power drinks you’ll find a mix of pure and synthetic sweeteners. These embrace the next:

Sucrose & Glucose

Sucrose is a disaccharide consisting of glucose and fructose. Glucose is an easy sugar or monosaccharide. It’s your physique’s most well-liked carb-based power supply. (2


Maltodextrin is a typical additive in processed meals fabricated from corn, rice, potato starch, or wheat. It is vitally just like corn syrup however with much less sugar content material. This ingredient serves a number of functions; it’s a sweetener, a thickener, and a preservative. 

Whereas the FDA has authorized of maltodextrin as a protected ingredient, it’s excessive within the glycemic index, that means it will possibly trigger a spike in blood sugar. So anybody with diabetes must be cautious of how a lot maltodextrin they consumption. (3

Acesulfame Potassium
Acesulfame potassium (Ace-Okay) is a sweetener that’s typically mentioned to be sweeter than desk sugar. As a result of it’s a non-sugar sweetener, it’s usually utilized in merchandise which can be sugar-free or low-sugar. There’s a controversy over the security of Ace-Okay, nonetheless, the FDA has maintained that it’s protected for consumption. (4)

Erythritol is a kind of sugar alcohol that’s thought-about protected. It doesn’t seem to have critical unwanted effects, however consuming an excessive amount of of it could trigger an upset abdomen. †

What about pure and synthetic flavoring?

The FDA defines pure flavors as any taste remoted from pure sources like crops. Whereas synthetic flavors are any flavors not remoted from pure sources, even when they’ve the precise chemical composition of pure flavors. Imagine it or not, many specialists say that pure and synthetic flavors aren’t that completely different. And that the drive to make use of pure flavors over synthetic is extra for advertising and marketing functions. (5)

With that every one mentioned, let’s begin evaluating! For the aim of the publish, we’ll be masking the most well-liked flavors/kinds of those merchandise. So there could also be variations between merchandise inside a model/sequence.

redbull pre workout vs energy drink

Crimson Bull®

Crimson Bull® is without doubt one of the hottest power drinks and has been for years. It encompasses a average quantity of caffeine that can assist you really feel awake with out feeling jittery.

At this level, you most likely have a superb understanding of caffeine. However, simply in case we’ll nonetheless go over it.


Caffeine is a central nervous system (CNS) stimulant. When it’s consumed and reaches your mind, you’ll discover the results like power and application. Due to this impact you’ll find caffeine in a variety of merchandise and drugs. 

However, caffeine additionally has some unwanted effects. An excessive amount of caffeine can result in complications and jitters, in addition to hypertension and even constructing a tolerance. Like most stimulants, once you construct tolerance to caffeine, you’ll want extra of it to realize the identical advantages somebody who isn’t tolerant would have. 

That’s why it’s essential to cycle your caffeine utilization. Whenever you don’t cycle your caffeine you create a dependence for it. And right here’s the factor, like most stimulants, caffeine is a drug and it’s a drug you will be hooked on. So the day you do overlook your morning espresso or Crimson Bull®, you will be greeted by some withdrawal signs like nervousness, irritability, and drowsiness (6,7


Caffeine is taken into account to be protected for consumption at as much as 400 mg (round Four cups of espresso) by the Mayo Clinic. Per 250 ml can of Redbull, there’s 80 mg of caffeine (7). 



Taurine is an amino acid discovered generally within the mind. It serves a number of functions within the physique together with (8): 

  • Sustaining hydration and electrolytes
  • Regulates minerals corresponding to calcium
  • Helps the nervous system and eyes
  • Regulate immune system features

However, taurine additionally might enhance train efficiency research counsel that taurine might support in eradicating waste merchandise that result in fatigue and muscle burn. What this interprets to is it being efficient for selling endurance, rising alertness and enhancing restoration. (9


Taurine could also be environment friendly when dosed at 500 to 3000 mgs. (10

Sodium Bicarbonate

The following ingredient is one thing all of us have someplace in our houses, sodium bicarbonate aka baking soda. So why have it in redbull? Sodium bicarbonate may very well assist enhance efficiency in high-intensity workout routines (extra analysis is required). In addition to enhance muscle coordination and enhance energy. (11,12


 Sodium bicarbonate is efficient when dosed at 90 to 135 mg. (11

Magnesium Carbonate

Magnesium has a ton of features within the physique from power creation to genetic upkeep. So it ought to come to no shock it performs a job in train efficiency as effectively. Outcomes are combined throughout the research, so we would want extra proof to be definitive what facets are being improved. (13,14,15) Magnesium Carbonate, nonetheless, is utilized in merchandise as a drying agent† and is a typical over-the-counter treatment for heartburn and upset abdomen (16).


The usual dose for magnesium is 200 to 400mg.†

monster pre workout vs energy drink


The following power drink we’re going over is Monster. Monster’s components options just a little extra components than Crimson Bull® and virtually doubles the serving dimension.

However, there are a number of components that we’ve already gone over. This contains:

Which leaves:

L-Carnitine L-Tartrate

L-Carnitine performs a vital position in power manufacturing by transporting fatty acids into your cells’ mitochondria. The place, your mitochondria makes use of these acids to create power. (17)

There may be additionally proof (although combined) that L-carnitine l-tartrate might profit train efficiency. This can be by way of enhancing restoration, rising oxygen provide, bettering stamina, and lowering muscle soreness. (18,19)


Doses of two grams or much less are thought-about protected for most individuals. There are some potential unwanted effects, together with nausea and abdomen discomfort. (20


As a result of sodium is a significant salt in sweat, drinks might embrace sodium or different variations of salt to help in rehydration. (21)


Analysis means that consuming about 450 mg or extra sodium per hour of train is required to take care of plasma quantity and sodium ranges. (21


Glucuronolactone is a sugar acid that’s naturally occurring within the physique. This can be a widespread ingredient present in power drinks and pre exercises alike, however what it does isn’t very clear. There are some research that counsel it could enhance power and application, however extra analysis is required to assist this. (22


Guarana Extract

Guarana is a plant native to the Amazon with seeds which will comprise 4 occasions extra caffeine than espresso beans. Due to this, guarana might promote the identical results of caffeine. This contains bettering power, alertness, and will even enhance metabolism. (23


Among the best facets of guarana extract is that just a little goes a great distance. The cognitive advantages have been famous at doses as little as 37mg to as excessive as 300mg. (24)  

Panax Ginseng Root Extract

Panax Ginseng is a slow-growing root that has been utilized in Chinese language medication for hundreds of years. There are a number of helpful features of ginseng, however one which we’re most fascinated with is the mind features. Research counsel ginseng may assist enhance cognitive features like reminiscence, social functioning, and temper. (25)


Research counsel that dosages from 200 to 400mg is efficient for bettering psychological efficiency and quietness. (26,27)


Inositol is a kind of sugar that serves a number of features, in addition to play a structural position in your physique’s cell membranes. It’s advantages vary from aiding in nervousness problems like panic dysfunction to benefiting metabolic syndrome danger elements and will assist stop gestational diabetes. Nonetheless, extra analysis is required total. In a pre exercise or power drink, inositol could also be helpful as a vasodilator and will support in lowering blood strain. (28,29,30,31)

reign pre workout vs energy drink


Reign™ is without doubt one of the newer power drinks to return out final yr and it’s mirrored within the components. The one non-preservative ingredient we’ve already gone over is caffeine. And there’s truly a big quantity of caffeine in a can of Reign™ (300 mg). So when you’re delicate to caffeine this will not be the correct drink for you.

The components right here that we’ve already gone over embrace:

The components we haven’t reviewed embrace:

amino acids
L-Leucine, L-Isoleucine, and L-Valine

L-Leucine, L-IsoLeucine, and L-Valine are sometimes seen collectively and acknowledged underneath the identify Branched Chain Amino Acids or BCAA. BCAA’s are nice for aiding in restoration and will support in stopping oxidative injury. (32)

As an alternative of typical dosage, BCAAs are sometimes referred to by their ratio. The commonest (and infrequently most well-liked) ratio is the two:1:1. This implies there’s twice the quantity of leucine than isoleucine or valine. The explanation behind this ratio is as a result of leucine could also be higher at stimulating protein synthesis and suppressing muscle protein breakdown than the opposite amino acids. (33)

Coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10)

Coenzyme Q10 is a naturally occuring nutrient within the physique that acts as an antioxidant. However, it additionally performs a job in metabolism, ATP manufacturing, might help stop complications and enhance train efficiency. (34,35,36)


There at present isn’t any particular dosage for CoQ10, the vary advised to be used is from 50 to 1,200 mg.†

5hour energy pre workout vs energy drink

5-Hour Vitality

Our final OTC power drink is extra of a shot than a drink, 5-Hour Vitality. This slightly below 2 fl oz, power shot guarantees round 5 hours of elevated power. Nonetheless, particular person outcomes will range. At 200 mg of caffeine, 1 full 5-Hour Vitality is across the equal of two cups of espresso. So this may very well be an awesome possibility for people on the lookout for a fast power enhance to get by way of a exercise shift.

Elements beforehand gone over embrace:

Which leaves us with:


Citicoline is a nootropic compound that converts to each choline and cytidine. Like most nootropics, it could support in boosting cognitive features like reminiscence and studying. (37) In actual fact, citicoline might even be used medicinally for cognitive impairments. (38)


Optimum dosages of Citicoline is round 500 to 2,000mg. (39

N-Acetyl L-Tyrosine

N-Acetyl-L-Tyrosine is a typical focus-enhancing ingredient present in pre exercises. So it’s used to advertise improved cognition. That features consideration, focus, reminiscence, and even temper. Apparently, researchers have discovered that these results could also be extra distinguished in people who’re delicate to stressors (40).


It seems there is no such thing as a set medical dosage for N-Acetyl L-Tyrosine, nonetheless, shoppers typically take between 700 to 1000 mg. †

mood boosters


Phenylalanine is an amino acid which will enhance temper, which is why it’s seen getting used to assist despair. (41) Analysis additionally means that this amino acid might support in fats oxidation (weight reduction). (42)


Dosages of L-Phenylalanine can vary. In a single examine, a max dose of two,500 mg was used, however others vary between 50 to100mg. (41)

Malic Acid

Malic acid is discovered naturally in vegatables and fruits like apples. It’s metabolized by the physique to create power.† It additionally could also be helpful for reinforcing immunity. (42) There is no such thing as a customary dose of malic acid that’s really helpful.


There are a bunch of advantages of Choline, however what it’s most acknowledged for is its position in cell construction, messaging, fats transport and metabolism, and DNA synthesis and nervous system upkeep. What this interprets to is improved mind features like reminiscence and focus (43).


Typical dosages for choline vary between 250 to 500 mg. †

bang pre workout vs energy drink


Bang® Vitality is our first pre exercise RTD, which comes from the makers of a beforehand in style RTD drink Redline, VPX sports activities. It truly is available in a RTD model and powdered, so when you moderately combine your pre exercise by yourself or management the dosing, you’ll be able to. However, Bang® isn’t the one pre exercise obtainable from VPX Sports activities. You too can go for their Shotgun pre workout, which options 5 complexes that can assist you attain your targets.

Beforehand reviewed components embrace:

That leaves us with:

  • EAAs
  • Magnesium Chloride
  • Creatyl-L-Leucine (Tremendous Creatine)
  • Calcium Chloride

the blend


EAAs include all 9 important amino acids, together with the three in BCAAs. Due to this fact the advantages carry over in addition to having its personal advantages.

This contains:

  • Elevated muscle development by stimulating protein synthesis.†
  • Decreased muscle soreness after intense exercises.†
  • Improved temper and sleep.†
  • Boosted metabolism.†
Magnesium Chloride

Magnesium Chloride is commonly used to deal with heartburn and constipation. However, analysis suggests it could assist relieve muscle soreness. (44)


The dose for Magnesium Chloride ranges from 310 to round 420 mg relying on age and intercourse.†


Tremendous Creatine consists of creatine bonded with L-Leucine. This mixture could also be extra soluble than both element alone. Collectively, they could support in rising muscle hypertrophy, muscle energy, restore, protein synthesis and extra. (45) There is no such thing as a present customary dose for tremendous creatine that’s really helpful.

Calcium Chloride

Calcium Chloride is commonly used as an electrolyte in sport drinks to help in re-hydration. (21)

c4 pre workout vs energy drink


C4 from Cellucor is one other in style RTD power drink and pre exercise. Whereas there’s at present an RTD C4 for the unique C4, there are additionally a number of different variations of C4. This contains C4 Ultimate, C4 Ultimate Shred, C4 Ripped,and C4 Extreme Energy.

Beforehand gone over components embrace:

That leaves us with:

  • Beta-Alanine
  • L-Citrulline
  • Betaine Anhydrous

Beta-alanine might support in buffering away lactic acid build-up. Lactic acid builds up in our muscle tissue after we exercise, inflicting the “burn” impact. With beta-alanine, this impact is delayed. Permitting you to proceed your exercise (46).

However, lactic acid isn’t all dangerous, lactate can be utilized by the mitochondria (powerhouse of the cell) for power. Moreover, it could even be helpful for muscle development (47).


The overall really helpful dosage for beta-alanine is between 2 to five grams each day. However, to keep away from the tingling sensation, it’s possible you’ll wish to go for a decrease dosage. (48)



Citrulline is a typical and efficient ingredient for rising blood circulate to muscle tissue through vasodilation (49). The place vasodilation refers back to the widening of arteries or veins.


For train efficiency, a dosage of 6 to eight grams is really helpful for citrulline. (50)

Betaine Anhydrous

Betaine Anhydrous is just like Citrulline in that it promotes higher blood circulate. This may be expressed as improved physique composition, elevated endurance and energy output. (51)


A dose between 2.5 to five grams of betaine could also be helpful for elevating plasma betaine ranges and improve sports activities efficiency. (51)

nitraflex pre workout vs energy


Nitraflex is one other in style pre exercise. In contrast to its rivals on this publish, it’s possible you’ll not discover Nitraflex RTD as simply as coming to your native 7 Eleven. The excellent news is that its powder model is what established Nitraflex within the pre exercise sport and we preserve that in inventory. However, like C4, there are different variations of Nitraflex obtainable; together with, Nitraflex Pump and Nitraflex Burn.

Beforehand reviewed components embrace:

That leaves us with:

  • Citrulline Malate
  • L-Arginine Malate 
  • L-Arginine Alpha-Ketoglutarate
  • Calcium Fructopyranose Borate (CFB) FruiteX-B
Citrulline Malate

Citrulline Malate is one other model of citrulline. So it has the identical advantages of aiding in blood circulate and endurance. Even the really helpful dosage is identical. Nonetheless, analysis means that the addition of the malic acid (represented as Malate), this model might enhance stamina and cut back ache higher than the citrulline alone. (52)

L-Arginine Malate & L-Arginine Alpha-Ketoglutarate (AAKG)

Arginine is one other endurance boosting agent. When arginine is consumed, the physique converts it to Nitric Oxide, the place it’s then in a position to enhance vasodilation. (53) Relating to L-Arginine Malate VS AAKG, there are claims that AAKG could also be higher at absorption†. Nonetheless, there’s not sufficient analysis evaluating these two components to assist this.


The usual dose for Arginine is three to six grams.There is no such thing as a present differentiation between dosing for L-arginine malate vs AAKG.

Calcium Fructopyranose Borate (CFB) FruiteX-B

Calcium fructoborate is a type of boron that might support in naturally boosting testosterone (54).


Analysis means that on the dose of 220mg each day, CFB could also be helpful for joint ache.Nonetheless, there’s not a longtime dosage for rising testosterone. (55)  

alani nu pre workout vs energy drink

Alani Nu

Alani Nu is without doubt one of the newer manufacturers we see rocketing within the RTD power drinks household. Like our different pre exercises, it’s featured as each an RTD power drink and a powdered pre exercise. One of many extra notable options from Alani Nu Pre Exercises, in addition to it’s clear and glossy design, is the number of flavors obtainable. From Mimosa to Hawaiian Shaved Ice, there’s a tasty drink to get you thru your work-day to exercise.

Beforehand reviewed components embrace:

Leaving us with simply:


Theanine is taken into account an anti-stress amino acid with a “rest with out sedation” impact. However, when mixed with Caffeine, there could also be a synergistic impact. Analysis means that this mix might promote heightened focus, consciousness, and power. (56)


The really helpful dose is between 100 to 250mg of Theanine. (56)

Gum Acacia

Gum Acacia or Gum Arabic is extensively utilized in drinks to assist delay sugar crystallization, stabilizing emulsion to fats.†

pre workout vs energy drink safe

Are They Protected

Now that we’ve in contrast a bunch of merchandise, what have we realized?

  • There are a bunch of components which can be shared between each power drinks and pre exercises.
  • “Pure” doesn’t at all times imply higher.
  • There are a ton of preservatives and sweeteners in RTD drinks.
  • Vitality drinks can include a big quantity of energy. 

It’s these final two bullet factors that ought to make you assume twice on what you’re buying once you’re on the lookout for a fast repair. Whereas energy are most actually not the dangerous man, when you’re trying to drop some weight it’s possible you’ll wish to save your energy for meals over drinks. 

As for preservatives…

It ought to make sense that there are a ton of them in RTD drinks, afterall, they’re made ready-to-drink. So the preservatives are there to take care of shelf-time. You will discover preservatives in virtually something, however generally too many may cause some concern.

There are some stories that counsel the chemical compounds utilized in preservatives have unwanted effects, which may vary from delicate to life-threatening. A few of the unwanted effects embrace: Complications, palpitations, allergic reactions(pores and skin rashes) and even most cancers. (57

So what do you have to do about it? 

Do your analysis when you really feel like it’s possible you’ll be experiencing a aspect impact associated to preservatives and take notice if different meals trigger the identical response. You’ll wish to keep away from these merchandise or seek for higher choices. Typically, the much less preservatives in your weight-reduction plan, the higher. 

What about sweeteners?

Like we talked about earlier within the publish, there are a bunch of synthetic sweeteners that the FDA has authorized of as protected. However, synthetic and pure sweeteners alike, have dangers. 

for the gym

Which Is Extra Efficient For The Gymnasium

As for the fitness center, you’ll wish to goal for a product that’s selling blood circulate and endurance. Afterall, that’s what is basically going that can assist you bust by way of PRs.

So search for merchandise containing:

  • Types of Citrulline
  • Types of Arginine
  • Betaine
  • Creatine
  • Beta Alanine
  • Glycerol 

You may additionally wish to go for a product with nootropics or cognitive enhancers to help within the tunnel imaginative and prescient results. So components like:

bang for your buck

How To Get The Most Bang For Your Buck


It comes right down to a easy precept of price-per-serving. In case you’re buying an power drink a day (this contains your espresso) for $Four-5, you’re spending a minimal of $120 a month. Whereas you will get a case of 12 for typically round $30. Or when you actually wish to get monetary savings, you should buy a powder model of a pre exercise for roughly the identical value because the case, however get 30 servings (or extra when you don’t take a full scoop).

putting it all together

Placing It All Collectively

When it comes right down to nitty-gritty, it’s all about your desire and what matches your life-style. Us at Similar Day Dietary supplements wish to take pleasure in a wide range of pre exercises and power drinks. However, in the case of the fitness center, we have a tendency to stay with a pre exercise. Thanks for studying and if there’s one other product you’d like us to evaluate, an ingredient that you simply assume wants additional elaboration, or one other weblog concept you wish to see sooner or later– ship us an e-mail here or depart a remark under!


The intention of the data offered is for reference solely and we’re on no account offering medical recommendation or instruction. The data offered on this publish relies on anecdotal info and obtainable research/opinions. Whereas it’s our aim to take care of and show correct info, we are able to’t assure it represents the newest formulation of the product or info. Due to this fact, when you have any considerations, please go to the producer’s web site. Additionally, the data above will not be a illustration of our views at Similar Day Dietary supplements. Moderately, these are the views and knowledge offered by producers and customers. Additionally, the Meals and Drug Administration has not evaluated these statements. Lastly, the intention of those merchandise is to not diagnose, deal with, treatment or stop any illness or sickness.


Leave a Reply